4. Romantic Suspense
Romantic suspense blends:
-
- Fast-paced, thriller-style pacing: Featuring cliffhangers, ticking clocks, and growing stakes that keep readers turning pages late into the night.
- Crime or danger-driven storylines: Kidnappings, serial offenders, organized crime, or covert operations that place the protagonists in immediate jeopardy.
- Protective, heroic, or morally complex leads: Detectives, bodyguards, and special agents are forced into extraordinary bravery and decide how far they're willing to go for the person they love.
Think Killing Eve, You, Behind Her Eyes, The Bodyguard, Basic Instinct, Gone Girl, Rebecca, Body Heat, and The Jagged Edge.
Why it works:
This is a natural fit for readers who love thrillers and crime fiction, so it can help you connect with audiences well beyond traditional romance fans. This sub-genre also tends to inspire strong series read-through, making it especially rewarding for long-term, ongoing projects. Once readers bond with your world and recurring characters, they'll likely follow you from book to book.
Read our interview with romantic suspense author Jill Ramsower for more insight into this subgenre.
5. Historical Romance
Historical romance continues to be a strong commercial sub-genre, especially when:
-
- The time period feels rich and immersive: Well-researched dialogue, historical events, and period-specific touches such as food, fashion, and transportation help the story feel transportive.
- The characters feel modern and have relatable inner lives: Even though the setting is historical, readers still expect to encounter emotional experiences they recognize.
- The setting is visually distinct and memorable: Regency ballrooms, Gilded Age mansions, seaside resorts, and frontier towns give the story a cinematic feel.
Think Pride and Prejudice, Atonement, Titanic, Bridgerton, Downton Abbey, The Buccaneers, and North and South.
Why it works:
Historical romance readers are incredibly loyal and, once they're hooked on the genre, they tend to stay with it for the long haul.
Read our interview with author Marta Molnar, who writes historical fiction with a bit of romance, for more insight into this sub-genre.
The two sub-genres below typically have high reader engagement and strong community loyalty, but smaller total volume.
6. Paranormal Romance
Paranormal romance combines a central love story with supernatural elements, where those otherworldly aspects heighten the emotional and romantic stakes rather than pulling focus away from the relationship. Readers expect:
-
-
One or both characters to possess supernatural abilities or non-human traits: Vampires, shifters, witches, angels and demons, magically gifted humans, and more.
-
Themes of “forbidden love” and outsider identity: This emotional core is one of the genre’s strongest appeals. Includes loving someone you shouldn't, being misunderstood, and intimacy overcoming physical or societal barriers.
-
Blending romance with suspense, fantasy, or danger: External stakes such as rival supernatural factions or dangerous magical forces raise the emotional stakes of the relationship.
-
Think Ghost, Only Lovers Left Alive, Warm Bodies, True Blood, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Being Human, and The Originals.
Why It Works: Paranormal romance excels because the supernatural elements heighten the emotions of falling in love, amplifying desire, fear, and vulnerability beyond what’s possible in realistic settings.
Read our interview with fantasy and paranormal romance author Juliette Cross for more insight into this genre.
7. LGBTQ+ Romance
LGBTQ+ romance novels share the same structure as all romance: an emotionally central love story with a satisfying resolution. However, they often include additional layers related to identity, belonging, and social context. Traits include:
-
- Identity exploration is often part of the emotional journey: Many novels include characters who're learning to fully accept themselves, coming out to family or friends, and navigating identity in personal and professional settings.
- Themes of belonging and acceptance are central: A recurring emotional thread is the longing to be fully seen and accepted—romantically, socially, and personally—while building chosen family and overcoming isolation.
- Modern novels increasingly center on joy: Contemporary LGBTQ+ romance emphasizes healthy relationships, happiness, intimacy, and everyday romantic experiences rather than primarily focusing on the trauma or rejection detailed in earlier fiction of this genre.
Think Call Me By Your Name, Carol, Moonlight, Heated Rivalry, Heartstopper; Red, White, and Royal Blue, and Fellow Travelers.
Why it works: LGBTQ+ romance works because it delivers the familiar pleasures of romance while offering representation, emotional depth, and joyful, affirming endings that many readers can't easily find elsewhere.
What This Means for Indie Authors
Here is the part many authors overlook: Romance isn't just about “writing what you love.” It's also about channeling your creativity into the areas where readers are already eager and waiting.
Sub-Genre Choice Is a Strategic Business Decision
Your sub-genre helps determine:
-
- Which keywords you can rank for
- Which algorithms are most likely to surface your book
- Which readers are most likely to see your cover
Choosing the right, high-demand sub-genre can sometimes lead to better results than even the most beautifully written books in quieter niches. It may not feel very romantic, but it’s a helpful reality to keep in mind as you plan your publishing strategy.
Romance Rewards Series, Not Standalones
Romance algorithms tend to reward:
-
- Authors with multiple books
- Familiar well-loved tropes
- Clear and consistent branding
If your goal is steady, reliable income rather than chasing literary awards, it’s usually smarter to plan a 3–7 book series instead of putting all your energy into a single standalone novel.
This is the point where many indie romance authors either build consistent growth or start to lose momentum, so being intentional about series planning really matters.
Indie Authors Compete Best in Romance
Romance is one of the few genres in which:
-
- Indie authors often outsell traditional authors
- Readers care more about emotional payoff than which publisher is on the spine
- Fast release cycles are genuinely rewarded
In other words, romance is inherently open and accessible. Readers, not critics, shape the market and decide which stories rise to the top.
Discoverability Is Driven by Tropes, Not Prose
Readers are actively searching for:
-
- “Enemies to lovers”
- “Grumpy sunshine”
- “Small town romance”
- “Slow burn romantasy”
They're not usually typing in:
-
- “Beautifully written coming-of-age novel”
If your metadata, blurb, and categories don’t clearly spotlight your key tropes, it’ll be much harder for the right readers to discover your book.
The Bottom Line
Romance isn't saturated…it's simply segmented. There's infinite demand, but it's strongest for authors who:
-
- Understand their sub-genre
- Write to reader expectations
- Brand themselves consistently
- Think in terms of series, not just single books
- Treat discoverability as part of the craft
Romance is about as close as publishing gets to a predictable commercial ecosystem.
If you're looking for a genre that readers are actively buying, for which algorithms are relatively forgiving, and in which indie authors can thrive…romance isn't just a good option; it's one of your best.





